Is Adoption Morally Superior to 3rd Party Reproduction?
Every so often, we get a whiff of superiority coming from a few folks in the adoption world—especially in relations to those who chose to create their family through third party reproduction (donor sperm, egg, embryo or surrogacy). I received the following email from a mom of two by donor egg:
Just listening to podcast on the emotions of infertility, which raised some really important points. I particularly connected to the question from a Mom who had a four year old adopted son and was thinking of using donor egg but felt ashamed/unsure of how or if to tell her adoption buddies about this.
I am a mother of two children by donor egg. This was actually my second choice to adoption. A legal change in Ireland (ratifying Hague convention) stopped anyone here adopting for a long time. I have found quite often when I post questions on support groups about talking and telling or feelings around having a donor conception child I get quite aggressive and hurtful comments back from the adoption ‘side’.
A particular example was when I asked if any other Moms of egg donor babies struggled with feelings that their child didn’t have a genetic link to their family; especially family members who had died before the baby was born. I lost my father before my son was born and sometimes struggled talking about ‘your grandfather’ to my son as technically he was not and in reality he was not never having seen or known him. It really made the lack of a genetic link painful.
A number of adoptive parents jumped in and gave me variations on:
- “yes I thought about issues like that, and that’s why I didn’t go for egg donation”. Or
- “It is weird/unnatural so what do you expect if you use third party reproduction. You should have adopted then the relationship would be more straightforward.”
None of which was very helpful.
I don’t know whether this is moral judgment against using third party reproduction, or unresolved pain at the loss of a pregnancy experience, or an evangelistic need to promote adoption. I could understand any of those points of view; however, I would have hoped that a community that has had to face infertility and deal with some pretty tough emotional stuff might have learned a little empathy along the way.
Maybe it’s time to open this discussion? As your psychologist on the show pointed out there are valid reasons why people may choose to use donor technology as well as, or instead of, adoption. The loss of a pregnancy/birth experience, giving our partners the chance to have a genetic child are valid reasons, and after the losses of multiple IVF rounds, not totally selfish reasons to make this choice. People adopting undeniably have the moral high ground. Adoption is a wonderful and amazing thing to be part of, but it’s not right to use this high ground to attack others who have taken a different path. After all many families who can reproduce ‘normally’ choose to do so, as well as adopt.
Who Has the Moral High Ground?
While I don’t see the condemnation or lack of support as much as the emailer does, I do think at times that some folks who adopt feel slightly superior to those who choose to use donor sperm, donor egg, donor embryo, or surrogacy. I see this more often with foster care adoption or international adoption, than with domestic infant adoption. Their reasoning seems to be that they took in kids who “truly needed” families, rather than create kids from scratch.
Reasons to Choose Third Party Reproduction
There are lots of reasons someone would choose donor sperm, egg, embryo or surrogacy over adoption.
- Wanting to experience pregnancy and breastfeeding.
- Wanting one parent to have a genetic connection to the child.
- Control over the prenatal environment.
- Cost (especially when using donor embryo).
- Time involved.
- Third party reproduction feels more comfortable because it is treated like the next step up the infertility escalator.
Let’s Get Off Our High Horse
Growing up, if I started getting a bit smug, my mom would be quick to tell me: Get off your high horse, missy!
The way each of us chooses to create our family is intensely personal. This is especially the case for those who have struggled with infertility. What is best for one person is not necessarily best for someone else. In the end, most of us just want to be parents and are looking for the easiest/fastest/most comfortable/best way to do it.
Being on top, means someone else has to be on the bottom, so let’s stop the competition for the moral high ground. The high ground ain’t all is cracked up to be.
Why did you choose your way of creating your family, be it donor sperm, egg, embryo, or surrogacy.
Other Creating a Family resources you will enjoy:
- Exhausting Competition Between Adoption and Infertility
- Should You Tell Family/Friends You Used Donor Sperm/Egg/Embryo
- Top Ten Tips for Creating Your Family Through Surrogacy
- Teens Born Via Sperm/Egg Donation or Surrogacy Are Doing Fine
Image credit: Peter Thoeny